Home > Forum > Who posts the most TRs on TAY??

Who posts the most TRs on TAY??

  • Amar Andalkar
  • Topic Author
  • User
  • User
More
15 years 1 month ago #196580 by Amar Andalkar
Replied by Amar Andalkar on topic Re: Who posts the most TRs on TAY??

Yeah, interesting. Just the other day I was trying to remember when this all began; now I know for me--my first trip report here was April 2001 (unless there were trip reports before that that are not in the newer database).


Since the TAY Trip Reports didn't actually become a user-postable forum until October 2002 (TRs were added manually by Charles prior to that), posts before that month are not fully and properly counted by the script.

If you look through the old TR months prior to that, you can see that the OP's name is usually listed in plain text, not as a link to a user profile, and often the name listed does not exactly match any current TAY username. Even if the name does happen to match, the user number (which would be in the link to the user profile) is missing if the name is unlinked. Thus the PHP script has no way of properly assigning such posts to their proper author, since all of that is done based on user number. So there is some unavoidable undercounting of the older manual posts prior to October 2002, and those are not fully included in the totals for most early-joining TAY members.

For example, in Trip Reports - April 2001 , there is one TR by "acarey" , properly linked to user number 3 (!!), and two other TRs by "Andy Carey", not linked to any user number. So the PHP script is only counting one of those under acarey's totals, since it has no way of knowing for sure that acarey and Andy Carey are the same user.

This could be fixed by editing the TAY database (Marcus?) to assign those older posts properly to specific user numbers, in cases like yours where there is no ambiguity or uncertainty. In a few cases, it might not be possible to make that determination for sure though, if the listed name is not sufficiently similar to an actual TAY username, or without "inside knowledge" of username - realname correlation in such cases.

Such editing was already partially done at some point, which is why some of the pre-Oct2002 posts do have a linked user number. But it's probably not worth the effort to fix it more completely, just for the sake of historical counting.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Marcus
  • User
  • User
More
15 years 1 month ago #196581 by Marcus
Replied by Marcus on topic Re: Who posts the most TRs on TAY??
This is the kind of thing that I'll probably endeavor to do when I get around to upgrading the forum software (which is not even on the horizon, at this point). Interesting stuff Amar, thanks again.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Andrew Carey
  • User
  • User
More
15 years 1 month ago #196584 by Andrew Carey
Replied by Andrew Carey on topic Re: Who posts the most TRs on TAY??



For example, in Trip Reports - April 2001 , there is one TR by "acarey" , properly linked to user number 3 (!!), and two other TRs by "Andy Carey", not linked to any user number. So the PHP script is only counting one of those under acarey's totals, since it has no way of knowing for sure that acarey and Andy Carey are the same user.
...


they are, of course, the same person :-) I vaguely remember having to re-register at one point after Charles made some software changes. acarey was the last and present name used; I used Andy Carey, and, I think at one time "abc" (my initials) but that might have been on telemarque.com.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • ron j
  • User
  • User
More
15 years 1 month ago #196589 by ron j
Replied by ron j on topic Re: Who posts the most TRs on TAY??
I remember you posting as "abc" here.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • ron j
  • User
  • User
More
15 years 1 month ago #196590 by ron j
Replied by ron j on topic Re: Who posts the most TRs on TAY??
Back then ther was also a "Ron Jarvis" posting, which many confused as me.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Marcus
  • User
  • User
More
15 years 1 month ago #196591 by Marcus
Replied by Marcus on topic Re: Who posts the most TRs on TAY??

Back then ther was also a "Ron Jarvis" posting, which many confused as me.


There also appears to have been a "ron jarvis". A miscreant, no doubt.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.