- Posts: 267
- Thank you received: 0
"Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
- JibberD
-
Topic Author
- User
-
Less
More
18 years 11 months ago - 18 years 11 months ago #177622
by JibberD
Replied by JibberD on topic Re: "Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
This is a fun mystery.
At this point I like Lowell's "breaking wave" idea best. cascadianwarrior's pic shows one where the leading edge looks look a curled wave folding into itself.
Maybe the wind blows out the loose stuff from the middle? Maybe they form with the hole already there? I guess we won't know for sure until someone sees it happen live and shares the recipe. MMMMM doughnuts
TonyM: sometimes when I pee in the snow it looks kinda like that
At this point I like Lowell's "breaking wave" idea best. cascadianwarrior's pic shows one where the leading edge looks look a curled wave folding into itself.
Maybe the wind blows out the loose stuff from the middle? Maybe they form with the hole already there? I guess we won't know for sure until someone sees it happen live and shares the recipe. MMMMM doughnuts
TonyM: sometimes when I pee in the snow it looks kinda like that
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Lowell_Skoog
-
- User
-
Less
More
- Posts: 1460
- Thank you received: 16
18 years 11 months ago - 18 years 11 months ago #177623
by Lowell_Skoog
Replied by Lowell_Skoog on topic Re: "Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
Cascadianwarrior, is that a donut or a sticky bun?

What I mean is, does it have a hole in the middle?
I'm leaning toward my first hypothesis. The wheel does not initially have a hole in the center, but at some point the center falls out, creating a donut.
Cascadianwarrior's picture illustrates how this happens, I think. The wheel starts as a small snowball. As it rolls, it picks up more snow. When the snow conditions are right, the wheel grows not just in diameter (becoming a bigger disk) but also in thickness (the wheel's "tread" becomes wider). This can be seen clearly in Cascadianwarrior's picture. The outer edge of the wheel is not only thicker than the core, it is also more firmly packed. This happens because the wheel gets heavier as it grows, so the snow farthest from the center is packed under more weight. The inner, less consolidated core either melts or breaks away at some point.
===
Edited to add: I think some sort of heat source under the snow made the hole in TonyM's picture. Maybe a critter. I've seen holes sort of like this near marmot burrows.
What I mean is, does it have a hole in the middle?
I'm leaning toward my first hypothesis. The wheel does not initially have a hole in the center, but at some point the center falls out, creating a donut.
Cascadianwarrior's picture illustrates how this happens, I think. The wheel starts as a small snowball. As it rolls, it picks up more snow. When the snow conditions are right, the wheel grows not just in diameter (becoming a bigger disk) but also in thickness (the wheel's "tread" becomes wider). This can be seen clearly in Cascadianwarrior's picture. The outer edge of the wheel is not only thicker than the core, it is also more firmly packed. This happens because the wheel gets heavier as it grows, so the snow farthest from the center is packed under more weight. The inner, less consolidated core either melts or breaks away at some point.
===
Edited to add: I think some sort of heat source under the snow made the hole in TonyM's picture. Maybe a critter. I've seen holes sort of like this near marmot burrows.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Jonathan_S.
-
- User
-
Less
More
- Posts: 290
- Thank you received: 0
18 years 10 months ago #177647
by Jonathan_S.
Critter - you mean a Sasquatch? Okay, maybe a baby Sasquatch given the hole's size.
Here's what an adult Sasquatch hole/lair looks like:
picasaweb.google.com/jshefftz/WhenSasqua...#5042150575205281634
Oh, and the snow donut story made it onto NPR Monday! Between that and the incidents on Mt Doom, err, I mean, Mt Hood, NPR is quite the source this season for ski mountaineering coverage.
Replied by Jonathan_S. on topic Re: "Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
I think some sort of heat source under the snow made the hole in TonyM's picture. Maybe a critter. I've seen holes sort of like this near marmot burrows.
Critter - you mean a Sasquatch? Okay, maybe a baby Sasquatch given the hole's size.
Here's what an adult Sasquatch hole/lair looks like:
picasaweb.google.com/jshefftz/WhenSasqua...#5042150575205281634
Oh, and the snow donut story made it onto NPR Monday! Between that and the incidents on Mt Doom, err, I mean, Mt Hood, NPR is quite the source this season for ski mountaineering coverage.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- blitz
-
- User
-
Less
More
- Posts: 201
- Thank you received: 0
18 years 10 months ago #177654
by blitz
Replied by blitz on topic Re: "Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
Doug, when are we going to see TR from Deutchland? :
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- cascadianwarrior
-
- User
-
Less
More
- Posts: 22
- Thank you received: 0
18 years 10 months ago #177667
by cascadianwarrior
It was a true doughnut and a beauty at that!
I kinda messed up on the exposure but here are a couple more pictures of said doughnut:
Also, this story is picking up momentum (just like the doughnut :
). Here's an article from today's Wenatchee World:
Snow Doughnuts
And lastly, here is the ultimate specimen from Sandpoint, ID. They really know how to grow 'em in Idaho. I think it's even steel belted!
Replied by cascadianwarrior on topic Re: "Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
Cascadianwarrior, is that a donut or a sticky bun?
![]()
What I mean is, does it have a hole in the middle?
It was a true doughnut and a beauty at that!
I kinda messed up on the exposure but here are a couple more pictures of said doughnut:Also, this story is picking up momentum (just like the doughnut :
Snow Doughnuts
And lastly, here is the ultimate specimen from Sandpoint, ID. They really know how to grow 'em in Idaho. I think it's even steel belted!
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- garyabrill
-
- User
-
Less
More
- Posts: 464
- Thank you received: 0
18 years 10 months ago #177813
by garyabrill
Replied by garyabrill on topic Re: "Snow Doughnuts"...anyone seen one?
I think Lowell's first point is correct. It begins with a small snowball which often encounters friction and loses it's radial motion, which starts a sluff. Then the sluff hangs up a bit from friction, sticks to the surface snow layer, and begins, once again to rotate. The dougnut or "pinwheel" tends to pick up the amount of unstable, sticky snow available on each revolution. If the pinwheel gets big enough, or is somehow deflected it may fall over, which ordinarily will cause a loose, wet slide.
I've had fun with these on occasion. The biggest snowballs I've gotten going probably reached 5-8 feet in diameter before falling over. Some initiated avalanches of 4-8' of sliding wet (moist) snow.
In the first revolution the snow that congeals to form the core doesn't become compressed because the snowball has yet to gain much mass, but as it gets bigger with each revolution, the compression of the adhering snow layer becomes greater and greater. So, me thinks that the central core is more of a loose amalgamation than the surrounding layers that accumulate. Probably, that allows for the loosely packed center to fall out under the right circumstances.
I've had fun with these on occasion. The biggest snowballs I've gotten going probably reached 5-8 feet in diameter before falling over. Some initiated avalanches of 4-8' of sliding wet (moist) snow.
In the first revolution the snow that congeals to form the core doesn't become compressed because the snowball has yet to gain much mass, but as it gets bigger with each revolution, the compression of the adhering snow layer becomes greater and greater. So, me thinks that the central core is more of a loose amalgamation than the surrounding layers that accumulate. Probably, that allows for the loosely packed center to fall out under the right circumstances.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.